Butternut Box alternatives with an open price per day

At one-time prices on the Mersey Raw and Lily’s Kitchen websites on 21 October 2026, the table runs from Mersey Raw’s £1.71–2.56 to Lily’s Kitchen’s £11.22 a day.

Both are chicken recipes, but they are not equivalent comparisons. Mersey Raw is raw, with portions based on body weight rather than calories. Lily’s Kitchen is cooked, with portions calculated from its published calories. The lower raw-food rows need that distinction.

Pure Pet Food and Butternut Box give personalised prices after their quizzes. Estimated portions for this dog are 206 g of Pure’s dry food before adding water, or 616 g of Butternut Box using its published average calories across recipes.

Butternut Box’s website advertised “Fresh meals from: £2.34 / day” on 21 October 2026. That is the brand’s starting figure, not a quote for this dog. Its price depends on food quantity, delivery frequency and recipes; the Butternut Box cost guide explains those variables.

Pure Pet Food’s Awin-listed offer gives 30% off the first box and 10% off the second. Lily’s Kitchen’s Awin listing gives 25% off the first order. These introductory reductions are separate from the ongoing daily-price comparison.

Natures Menu says subscribers save 10% on every order, so that is an ongoing subscription reduction. Bella + Duke’s introductory offer also steps down across early boxes; it should not be applied to the Pets at Home shelf price.