FreshpetvsThe Farmer's Dog
Freshpet vs The Farmer's Dog: store fridge or delivery box
For a 30 lb adult at an estimated 744 kcal a day, neither Freshpet nor The Farmer's Dog has a verified daily price here. As of October 21, 2026, The Farmer's Dog quotes your plan after its quiz.
Freshpet
—
we haven’t read open prices or calories yet
The Farmer's DogTurkey
—
price after quiz · brand says from $2 a day
Freshpet: no open data. The Farmer's Dog: no calories published, price after quiz. 744 kcal a day for a 30 lb adult, neutered, 1–3 hours calm walks.
Estimates for healthy dogs at ideal weight. Ask your vet; weigh monthly and adjust. How we calculate
Same dog
What changes for the same dog?
The main gap is price visibility, not a demonstrated difference in cost. Neither brand has published recipe calories in this comparison, so a calorie-based daily portion and price cannot be calculated.
The shared starting point is a neutered, moderately active adult: about 744 kcal a day, with a 694–794 kcal range between methods. The calculation method uses FEDIAF, AAHA and WSAVA guidance; calorie estimates are starting points, not fixed portions.
A lower daily cost cannot be established without comparable recipe calories and prices.
Freshpet
- Type
- —
- Calories (label)
- not published
- Grams a day, 30 lb adult
- —
- Per day
- —
- Trustpilot
- 4.6 / 5 (1,277)
The Farmer's Dog
- Type
- Cooked
- Calories (label)
- not published
- Grams a day, 30 lb adult
- —
- Per day
- After quiz
- Trustpilot
- 3.9 / 5
Bowl by bowl
Your first two months, bowl by bowl
Thirty bowls a month for the dog above; a mark shows where a new box starts. Without published box prices the month is the price per day × 30.
Freshpet: we haven’t read open prices or calories yet. The Farmer's Dog: Price after the quiz; no calories or price on its open pages (Oct 21), Walmart showed no price.
- JFJustFoodForDogsBeef & Russet Potato · 477 g a daysimilar, with an open priceMonth 1$409.48boxes 1, 2, 3: $91.00 + $145.59 + $172.89 · one-time $545.97Month 2$345.78boxes 4, 5: $172.89 + $172.89 · one-time $363.98
Small: 14 × 18 oz lasts 15 days for this dog; a marked bowl starts a new box. Subscription terms on the brand page: “50% off 1st order, 20% off 2nd order, and 5% off future orders”. Checked Oct 21, 2026.
- VRViva RawBeef for Dogs · 527 g a daysimilar, with an open priceMonth 1$287.70$9.59 × 30 daysMonth 2$287.70$9.59 × 30 days
Catalog price for 2 lb (2 × 1 lb), spread per day: we don’t know how the brand splits it into boxes. Checked Oct 21, 2026.
Some buttons are partner links: we may earn a commission if you buy.
Recipes
Are both foods cooked?
Yes. Freshpet describes its recipes as gently steam-cooked and says its food is not raw. The Farmer's Dog describes its original Fresh product as gently cooked, too.
The recipe table identifies The Farmer's Dog Turkey. The brand also names beef, pork and chicken among its meats, but that ingredient list is not a recipe-by-recipe comparison. Freshpet's cooking description alone does not establish an equivalent recipe match.
Cooking style is shared; it does not establish equal portions or equal cost.
| Brand | Recipe | Type | kcal/kg |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Farmer's Dog | Turkey | Cooked | not published |
Ordering
How do ordering and storage differ?
On their websites, both brands advertise 50% off the first order or box—not the ongoing price. Freshpet advertises personalized delivery plans, a welcome kit and free shipping. The Farmer's Dog says plans depend on the dog's size and needs, with free, flexible deliveries.
Freshpet says all products must stay refrigerated. The Farmer's Dog says thawed packs keep in the fridge for up to four days and directs customers to account Settings to cancel.
Separate the introductory discount from the continuing plan, and check storage instructions before ordering.
| Freshpet | The Farmer's Dog | |
|---|---|---|
| How the plan is set | “the most personalized way to feed fresh Take the guesswork out of feeding…” | “Plans are priced based on your dog's size and needs.” |
| First box | “get 50% off your first order” | “Get 50% off your first box” |
| Delivery | “free welcome kit & free shipping on every order!” | “Free & flexible deliveries” |
| Storage | “All Freshpet products must be kept refrigerated at all times and used within 7 days of…” | “Once thawed, the packs should keep safely in the fridge for up to four days.” |
| Pause or cancel | not stated on its pages | “To cancel, navigate to your account and under the ‘Settings’ page…” |
Small to large
By the size of the dog
Adult dogs, neutered, calm walks of 1–3 hours. Where the brand shows no price, the column shows a similar brand with an open price.
Owners
What do ratings and recall searches show?
On October 21, 2026, Trustpilot showed Freshpet at 4.6 out of 5 from 1,277 reviews and The Farmer's Dog at 3.9 out of 5.
The FDA notice records Freshpet's June 13, 2021 voluntary recall of Select Small Dog Bite Size Beef & Egg Recipe for potential Salmonella contamination. The FDA-site search on the check date found no notice naming The Farmer's Dog; that is not a guarantee.
Trustpilot ratings and recall searches answer different questions; neither establishes nutritional suitability.
Which one, by situation
Which fits your shopping routine?
Freshpet fits a preference for store shelves as well as delivery. Its delivery service means the choice is not simply supermarket shopping versus a subscription.
The Farmer's Dog fits someone looking for its gently cooked Fresh product and a plan priced around their dog's size and needs. Gently cooked food is not exclusive to it: Freshpet describes steam-cooking, too.
Choose by shopping routine and plan terms, not an unverified price advantage.
Freshpet
you want store shelves as well as delivery.
The Farmer's Dog
you want gently cooked food.
Partner links
Where to check the price
- PetCheck price at PetPlate (partner link, opens in a new tab)partner link
Plate Gently cooked - JustCheck price at JustFoodForDogs (partner link, opens in a new tab)partner link
Food Gently cookedFor Dogs - We Feed RawRawCheck price at We Feed Raw (partner link, opens in a new tab)partner link
Buttons open the brand’s store in a new tab. They are partner links: if you buy, this site may earn a commission at no cost to you. Order and prices on this page do not depend on it.
Questions
Freshpet vs The Farmer's Dog: short answers
Is Freshpet cheaper than The Farmer's Dog?
A same-dog daily price comparison cannot be established here. The Farmer's Dog gives a personalized price after its quiz; compare that ongoing quote rather than its first-box discount.
Freshpet vs Farmers Dog: is either raw?
Freshpet says its food is fully cooked, not raw. The Farmer's Dog describes its original Fresh food as gently cooked.
Does Freshpet deliver like The Farmer's Dog?
Yes. Freshpet advertises customized meal plans delivered to your door, with free shipping. It also offers store shopping, so delivery is not the dividing line between the brands.
How long can The Farmer's Dog stay refrigerated?
The Farmer's Dog says thawed packs should keep safely in the fridge for up to four days. Freshpet says its products must be kept refrigerated at all times; follow the package's storage instructions.
Sources
- 1FEDIAF Nutritional Guidelines 2025europeanpetfood.org · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 2Trustpilot: www.freshpet.comtrustpilot.com · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 3FDA: Freshpet recalls one lot of Freshpet Select Small Dog Bite Size Beef & Egg Recipefda.gov · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 4Freshpet® Large Dog Multi-Protein Recipefreshpet.com · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 5Freshpet: Get in Touch – Contact Usfreshpet.com · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 6Freshpet: All Natural Dog Foodfreshpet.com · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 7The Farmer's Dog: Our Foodthefarmersdog.com · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 8Trustpilot: www.thefarmersdog.comtrustpilot.com · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 9The Farmer's Dog: Human-Grade Fresh Dog Food Deliverythefarmersdog.com · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 10The Farmer’s Dog Ingredients and Recipesthefarmersdog.com · checked Oct 21, 2026