JustFoodForDogsvsThe Farmer's Dog
JustFoodForDogs vs The Farmer's Dog: cost and recipes side by side
JustFoodForDogs costs an estimated $12.16 a day for a 30 lb adult; The Farmer’s Dog gives a quote after its quiz. As of October 21, 2026, the clearest difference is how much you can calculate before signing up.
JustFoodForDogsBeef & Russet Potato
477g
$12.16 a day · $370 a month
The Farmer's DogTurkey
—
price after quiz · brand says from $2 a day
JustFoodForDogs: 477 grams a day, $12.16 a day. The Farmer's Dog: no calories published, price after quiz. 744 kcal a day for a 30 lb adult, neutered, 1–3 hours calm walks.
Estimates for healthy dogs at ideal weight. Ask your vet; weigh monthly and adjust. How we calculate
Same dog
What differs for the same dog?
The estimate uses the $181.99 one-time price for Beef & Russet Potato listed on the JustFoodForDogs store on October 21, 2026. At 744 kcal a day, that means 477 g, or 16.8 oz, daily.
Both foods are cooked. The comparison gap is disclosure: The Farmer’s Dog does not publish an open price or Turkey calorie figure before its quiz. The calculation methods put this dog’s needs at 694–794 kcal a day; 744 is a starting estimate.
An open price and calorie label make JustFoodForDogs calculable before checkout, not necessarily cheaper.
JustFoodForDogs
- Type
- Cooked
- Calories (label)
- 1,559 kcal/kg
- Grams a day, 30 lb adult
- 477 g
- Per day
- $12.16
- Trustpilot
- 1.8 / 5
The Farmer's Dog
- Type
- Cooked
- Calories (label)
- not published
- Grams a day, 30 lb adult
- —
- Per day
- After quiz
- Trustpilot
- 3.9 / 5
Bowl by bowl
Your first two months, bowl by bowl
Thirty bowls a month for the dog above; a mark shows where a new box starts. Without published box prices the month is the price per day × 30.
The Farmer's Dog: Price after the quiz; no calories or price on its open pages (Oct 21), Walmart showed no price.
- JFJustFoodForDogsBeef & Russet Potato · 477 g a dayMonth 1$409.48boxes 1, 2, 3: $91.00 + $145.59 + $172.89 · one-time $545.97Month 2$345.78boxes 4, 5: $172.89 + $172.89 · one-time $363.98
Small: 14 × 18 oz lasts 15 days for this dog; a marked bowl starts a new box. Subscription terms on the brand page: “50% off 1st order, 20% off 2nd order, and 5% off future orders”. Checked Oct 21, 2026.
Some buttons are partner links: we may earn a commission if you buy.
Recipes
How do the recipes differ?
JustFoodForDogs lists Beef & Russet Potato at 1,559 kcal ME per kg as fed, compared with 922 for Fish & Sweet Potato and 872 for Venison & Squash. All are gently cooked.
For the same 30 lb adult, the fish recipe works out to 807 g daily versus 477 g for beef. The Farmer’s Dog lists Turkey here and also says its recipes include beef, pork and chicken.
Recipe calorie density changes the portion substantially, even within the same brand.
| Brand | Recipe | Type | kcal/kg |
|---|---|---|---|
| JustFoodForDogs | Beef & Russet Potato | Cooked | 1,559 |
| JustFoodForDogs | Fish & Sweet Potato | Cooked | 922 |
| JustFoodForDogs | Venison & Squash | Cooked | 872 |
| The Farmer's Dog | Turkey | Cooked | not published |
Four dogs
How much does each dog need?
The beef calculation rises from 189 g, or 6.7 oz, for the 10 lb adult to 955 g, or 33.7 oz, for the active 60 lb adult. Weight and activity both affect calorie needs; denser food requires fewer grams for the same calories.
The puppy row is arithmetic, not a feeding recommendation: JustFoodForDogs says this beef recipe is not intended for growing puppies. Ask your vet about puppy feeding. For adults, weigh monthly and adjust portions rather than treating the estimate as fixed.
Use the chart as a calorie-based starting point, and check the recipe’s life stage before choosing it.
- JustFoodForDogs · 10 lb adult$4.82189 g
- JustFoodForDogs · 30 lb adult$12.16477 g
- JustFoodForDogs · 60 lb active adult$24.33955 g
- JustFoodForDogs · 4-month puppy, 15 lb$14.70577 g
| JustFoodForDogs · 10 lb adult | 189 g |
|---|---|
| JustFoodForDogs · 30 lb adult | 477 g |
| JustFoodForDogs · 60 lb active adult | 955 g |
| JustFoodForDogs · 4-month puppy, 15 lb | 577 g |
Small to large
By the size of the dog
Adult dogs, neutered, calm walks of 1–3 hours. Where the brand shows no price, the column shows a similar brand with an open price.
| Dog | kcal a day | JustFoodForDogs, grams | JustFoodForDogs, price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 lb | 327 | 210 g | $5.34 $162/mo |
| 30 lb | 744 | 477 g | $12.16 $370/mo |
| 50 lb | 1,091 | 700 g | $17.82 $542/mo |
| 70 lb | 1,405 | 901 g | $22.95 $698/mo |
Ordering
What happens after the first box?
JustFoodForDogs advertises 50% off the first subscription order, 20% off the second and 5% off future orders. The Farmer’s Dog advertises 50% off its first box. Neither introductory discount is the ongoing price.
Storage instructions describe different stages: JustFoodForDogs lists up to 18 months frozen; The Farmer’s Dog says thawed packs keep refrigerated for up to four days. The Farmer’s Dog includes shipping with any plan and directs cancellation through account Settings.
Compare recurring charges and storage needs, not just the first-box discount.
| JustFoodForDogs | The Farmer's Dog | |
|---|---|---|
| How the plan is set | not stated on its pages | “Plans are priced based on your dog's size and needs.” |
| First box | “50% off 1st order, 20% off 2nd order, and 5% off future orders” | “Get 50% off your first box” |
| Delivery | “Free shipping on orders $49+” | “Free & flexible deliveries” |
| Storage | “Frozen Food | Up to 18 months (547 days) in the freezer.” | “Once thawed, the packs should keep safely in the fridge for up to four days.” |
| Pause or cancel | “To skip an item in a future order, under ‘Future Orders,’click ‘More Options’ next to the…” | “To cancel, navigate to your account and under the ‘Settings’ page…” |
Owners
What do ratings and recall searches show?
On October 21, 2026, Trustpilot showed JustFoodForDogs at 1.8 out of 5 and The Farmer’s Dog at 3.9 out of 5. Review counts were unavailable for both.
The FDA search on that date found a JustFoodForDogs recall notice published January 22, 2018, for potential Listeria monocytogenes contamination. It found no recall notice naming The Farmer’s Dog; that search result is not a guarantee.
Ratings summarize owner opinions; recall notices answer a separate question.
Which one, by situation
Which fits your buying preferences?
JustFoodForDogs fits a shopper who wants label calories and an open price before checkout, with store shelves as well as delivery. Its recipe choice still matters to both portion size and daily cost.
The Farmer’s Dog fits someone willing to complete a quiz for a personalized plan and quote. It describes its Fresh food as gently cooked, but that alone does not distinguish it from JustFoodForDogs. See the pricing guide before comparing your quote.
Choose by buying process and the quoted cost for your dog, not by a universal ranking.
JustFoodForDogs
you want an open price before checkout, calories on the label page, store shelves as well as delivery.
The Farmer's Dog
you want gently cooked food.
Partner links
Where to check the price
- JustCheck price at JustFoodForDogs (partner link, opens in a new tab)partner link
Food Gently cookedFor Dogs - PetCheck price at PetPlate (partner link, opens in a new tab)partner link
Plate Gently cooked - We Feed RawRawCheck price at We Feed Raw (partner link, opens in a new tab)partner link
Buttons open the brand’s store in a new tab. They are partner links: if you buy, this site may earn a commission at no cost to you. Order and prices on this page do not depend on it.
Questions
JustFoodForDogs vs The Farmer's Dog: short answers
Is JustFoodForDogs cheaper than The Farmer’s Dog?
A like-for-like price comparison needs The Farmer’s Dog’s quiz quote. JustFoodForDogs Beef & Russet Potato is estimated at $12.16 daily for the 30 lb adult, using the dated one-time store price above, excluding tax and shipping.
Are JustFoodForDogs and The Farmer’s Dog raw?
No. The recipes compared here are cooked. Both brands describe the food as gently cooked.
Why do JustFoodForDogs portions differ by recipe?
Calories per ounce differ. The same dog needs more grams of Fish & Sweet Potato than Beef & Russet Potato to reach the same calorie target.
Can puppies eat the JustFoodForDogs recipe compared here?
JustFoodForDogs says Beef & Russet Potato is for adult maintenance, not growing puppies. The puppy chart entry only illustrates the calculation; ask your vet to choose an appropriate puppy food.
Sources
- 1FEDIAF Nutritional Guidelines 2025europeanpetfood.org · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 2JustFoodForDogs: Beef Russet Potatojustfoodfordogs.com · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 3JustFoodForDogs: Fresh Fish Dog Food: White Fish & Sweet Potato Recipejustfoodfordogs.com · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 4JustFoodForDogs: Real Meat Venison Dog Food Recipejustfoodfordogs.com · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 5Trustpilot: justfoodfordogs.comtrustpilot.com · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 6FDA: JustFoodForDogs recalls three Daily Diets (possible Listeria monocytogenes)fda.gov · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 7The Farmer's Dog: Our Foodthefarmersdog.com · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 8Trustpilot: www.thefarmersdog.comtrustpilot.com · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 9The Farmer's Dog: Human-Grade Fresh Dog Food Deliverythefarmersdog.com · checked Oct 21, 2026
- 10The Farmer’s Dog Ingredients and Recipesthefarmersdog.com · checked Oct 21, 2026